Week 11 - Western Annotation


"That human will. You got to give homage to it. I seen it many times. 
It ain't so rare. But it is the best of us." (p. 44)


Author:  Sebastian Barry

TitleDays Without End

Genres:  Western, Historical Fiction, LGBT

Publication Date:  October 20, 2016

Number of Pages:  259

Geographical Setting:  American West / Midwest

Time Period:  1850's

Series:  Days Without End #1



Plot Summary:

Fleeing the Great Famine, Irish immigrant Thomas McNulty makes his way to America, where he meets John Cole; quickly forming a firm friendship as young men, they journey together, finding work, eventually joining the U.S. Army, and finding companionship between themselves as lovers. 

As soldiers, Thomas and John first find themselves mired within the brutal Indian Wars of 1850’s America, then caught up in the carnage of the Civil War. However, even experiencing the horrors of multiple wars, they make time for their personal relationship and act as caretakers for a young Sioux girl, who they call Winona and come to see as a daughter. Trying to not let the terrible wartime experiences they have faced overwhelm and consume their lives, Thomas and John, along with Winona, do their best to forge a life together as, for that time period, an unconventional family. 



Subject Headings:

West (U.S.)

Frontier and pioneer life

Immigrants, Irish

Soldiers

Man-man relationship

Indians of North America

United States Civil War, 1861-1865



Appeals:

Frame / Setting

"...take readers back to a time and place in which life is set against a dangerous but beautiful backdrop...[t]he setting is more rugged and merciless, yet more open to possibilities, than the confined landscapes of cities" (Wyatt & Saricks, 2019, p. 152).


Characterization

"The traditional hero is often a loner who arrives to right wrongs and then moves on. Heroes use strategy before guns to win arguments, although they are often, in the end, forced to use violence" (Wyatt & Saricks, 2019, p. 151).

"Women...often play important roles, and in much of the genre they are well drawn...Traditionally, female characters are usually either fallen women who turn out to have hearts of gold or good women who stand by their men and work to make a home in the wilderness" (Wyatt & Saricks, 2019, pp. 152-153).

Complex  -  LGBTQIA


Story Line

"...include damaged characters seeking escape, healing, or redemption. Renewal is such a strong theme in the genre that even 'bad guys' occasionally find this redemption. Betrayal and the consequent settling of scores..." (Wyatt & Saricks, 2019, p. 153).

Sweeping  -  Character-driven


Tone

"...there is a sense of longing for times past and an elegiac knowledge that these days will not come again...with gritty details of gunfights and violence underpinning the action..." (Wyatt & Saricks, 2019, p. 153).

Violent  -  Dramatic  -  Reflective  -  Moving


Pacing

"Many traditional Westerns have a quick pace. Action and adventure dominate these works...they zip along...However, not all Westerns are fast-paced. The creation of mythic elements in character, description, and plot may slow the pacing, as does the description of the landscape" (Wyatt & Saricks, 2019, p. 154).


Language / Style

"Dialogue is generally spare, colorful, and rich in jargon, but many Westerns also feature lyrical descriptions of the landscape" (Wyatt & Saricks, 2019, p. 151).



3 Terms That Best Describe This Book:  Descriptive, Emotional, Complex



3 Relevant Fiction Works and Authors:

Huck Out West by Robert Coover

At the end of Huckleberry Finn, on the eve of the Civil War, Huck and his pal Tom Sawyer “light out for the Territory” to avoid “sivilization.” In Robert Coover’s vision of their Western adventures, Huck and Tom start by joining the famous but short-lived Pony Express. 

Tom becomes something of a hero and decides he’d rather own civilization than escape it, returning east to get a wife and a law degree. But Huck stays alone in the Territory; he guides wagon trains, scouts for both sides in the war, wrangles horses on a Chisholm Trail cattle drive, joins a bandit gang, finds an ill-fated pal in an army fort and another in a Lakota Sioux tribe, and eventually finds himself in the Black Hills just ahead of the 1876 Gold Rush. In the course of his adventures, Huck reunites with Tom, Jim, and Becky Thatcher and faces some hard truths and harder choices.  --Goodreads



Common Appeals

American West - Journey - North American Indians




Wolves of Eden by Kevin McCarthy


1866, Dakota Territory. Red Cloud’s coalition of tribes is battling the U.S. Army to reclaim hunting grounds in the Powder River Valley. Against this background, Wolves of Eden sets four men on a deadly collision course in a narrative that explores the cruelty of warfare, the power of love and the resilience of the human spirit. Lieutenant Martin Molloy and his loyal orderly are sent west to investigate a triple murder at a frontier fort, and Irish immigrant brothers Thomas and Michael O’Driscoll, who survived the brutal frontlines of the Civil War, find themselves as both hunters and the hunted in another bloody campaign.  --Goodreads





Common Appeals

American West - Violent/Dramatic tone - Complex/Compelling writing style




Far As the Eye Can See by Robert Bausch

Bobby Hale is a Union veteran several times over. After the war, he sets his sights on California, but only makes it to Montana. As he stumbles around the West, from the Wyoming Territory to the Black Hills of the Dakotas, he finds meaning in the people he meets-settlers and native people-and the violent history he both participates in and witnesses. 

Far as the Eye Can See is the story of life in a place where every minute is an engagement in a kind of war of survival, and how two people-a white man and a mixed-race woman-in the midst of such majesty and violence can manage to find a pathway to their own humanity. 

 --Goodreads




Common Appeals

Complex characters - Lyrical writing style - American West - Civil War Era






3 Relevant Non-Fiction Works and Authors:

The American West by Dee Brown

Renowned storyteller Dee Brown, author of the bestselling Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee, recreates the struggles of Native Americans, settlers, and ranchers in this stunning volume that illuminates the history of the old West that’s filled with maps and vintage photographs.

Beginning with the demise of the Native Americans of the Plains, Brown depicts the onrush of the burgeoning cattle trade and the waves of immigrants who ultimately “settled” the land. In the retelling of this oft-told saga, Brown has demonstrated once again his abilities as a master storyteller and an entertaining popular historian.

By turns heroic, tragic, and even humorous, The American West brings to life American tragedy and triumph in the years from 1840 to the turn of the century, and a roster of characters both great and small: Red Cloud, Sitting Bull, Geronimo, Dull Knife, Crazy Horse, Captain Jack, John H. Tunstall, Billy the Kid, Pat Garrett, Wyatt Earp, the Hole-in-the-Wall Gang, Wild Bill Hickok, Charles Goodnight, Oliver Loving, Buffalo Bill, and many others.  --Amazon




The Civil War: A Narrative by Shelby Foote

3 Volumes: Fort Sumter to Perryville - Fredericksburg to Meridian - Red River to Appomattox
This beautifully written trilogy of books on the American Civil War is not only a piece of first-rate history, but also a marvelous work of literature. Shelby Foote brings a skilled novelist's narrative power to this great epic. Many know Foote for his prominent role as a commentator on Ken Burns's PBS series about the Civil War. These three books, however, are his legacy.
His southern sympathies are apparent: the first volume opens by introducing Confederate President Jefferson Davis, rather than Abraham Lincoln. But they hardly get in the way of the great story Foote tells.  
--Goodreads






The Mammoth Book of Native Americans: The Story of America's Original Inhabitants In All Its Beauty, Magic, Truth and Tragedy by Jon E. Lewis

Native Americans make up less than one per cent of the total US population but represent half the nation's languages and cultures. Here, in one grand sweep, is the full story of Native American society, culture and religion. Here is everything from the land-based spirituality of their early creation myths and the late rise of Indian Pride, to the 88 uses to which the Sioux put the flesh and bones of the buffalo and the practice of berdache (men adopted as women). 

The book offers a chronological history of America's indigenous peoples. It covers their dramatic early entry into North America, out of the now submerged continent of Beringia, then in more recent times the 'forgotten wars' of the 16th and 17th centuries, which wiped many tribes from the face of the East Coast, and finally describes to the last struggles of the Cheyenne and the Comanche. Celebrating these peoples' way of life rather than focusing narrowly on the manner of their genocide, it does not ignore uncomfortable facts of the Amerindian past - including the cannibalism believed to have been practised by some tribes and the Native Americans' part in the decimation of North America's buffalo herds.  --Goodreads















References



Goodreads. (2024). The Civil War: A Narrative. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/44242.Civil_War

Goodreads. (2024). The Mammoth Book of Native Americanshttps://www.goodreads.com/book/show/127388201-mammoth-book-of-native-americans


Wyatt, N., & Saricks, J. G. (2019). The readers’ advisory guide to genre fiction (3rd ed.). ALA Editions.

Comments

  1. The summary and appeals make this book sound fantastic! Great job writing those. The readalikes also look fantastic. I've never heard of this title before by it's on my tbr now!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Maryanne,

    I appreciate seeing an annotation for westerns, particularly with the recommendations you give. This is not a genre I can ever see myself reading, and it helps to see some newer titles. My library has a handful of old ones that linger because our western readers have limited choices and therefore they circulate, but I'd love to work on selecting some new ones.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts